Justice G.R. Swaminathan, a serving judge of the Madras High Court, has ignited widespread discussion and public controversy after asserting at a spiritual event in Tamil Nadu that individuals who do not believe in spiritual gurus are “rascals, fools and barbarians.” According to reports, the judge made these remarks while addressing followers of a spiritual organization, arguing that accepting a guru’s role is integral to moral and spiritual guidance. These comments have drawn sharp responses from various sections of the public and legal community, who contend that a sitting judge should refrain from making statements that could be viewed as insensitive or dismissive of rationalist viewpoints.
Justice Swaminathan’s remarks come amid ongoing debate over his earlier rulings, including a contentious order on lighting ceremonial lamps near a historic site in Thiruparankundram, which had already prompted an impeachment motion by more than a hundred Members of Parliament on grounds of perceived bias and undermining secular judicial principles. Critics argue that judicial figures must uphold constitutional neutrality, especially in matters touching on personal faith and public belief systems. Supporters of the judge, however, see his comments as an expression of personal conviction. The incident underscores broader tensions in Indian society between traditional spiritual values and modern rationalist perspectives.
Read more news at Hindustan (हिन्दुस्तान दैनिक) Newspaper